Editorial Policies

Editorial Policies

1. Editorial independence

Editorial decisions at IJCIE are made solely on the scholarly merit of the manuscript and its fit with the journal's scope. The publisher, DeepCognix AI Labs, does not intervene in the evaluation of individual manuscripts. Commercial considerations, including the article processing charge, play no part in acceptance decisions; the decision to accept is taken before any charge is invoiced.

2. Basis of decisions

Decisions are based on originality, technical soundness, validity of the evidence, clarity of presentation, relevance to the journal's readership and compliance with the journal's ethical requirements. The author's nationality, institution, seniority, gender, race, religion or political belief is never a factor.

3. Decision categories

  • Accept – publishable as submitted or with trivial edits.
  • Minor revision – publishable after limited changes, normally verified by the handling editor.
  • Major revision – substantive changes required; the revised manuscript is normally returned to the original reviewers.
  • Reject – the manuscript does not meet the journal's standards or scope. Rejection may occur before review (desk rejection) or after review.

4. Editors' own submissions

Editors, board members and the publisher's staff may submit to IJCIE. When they do, the submission is assigned to a different editor who has no working relationship with the author, the submitting editor has no access to the review file, and the decision is taken independently. Such articles carry a statement of the arrangement at the time of publication.

5. Confidentiality

A submitted manuscript is a confidential document. Editors and reviewers must not disclose, discuss or use its contents for any purpose other than the review, and must not share it with third parties without the editor's permission. Unpublished material from a submitted manuscript must never be used in an editor's or reviewer's own research.

6. Conflicts of interest in editorial handling

An editor must decline to handle a manuscript if there is a recent co-authorship, a shared institution, a supervisory relationship, a financial interest or a personal relationship with any author. Declared conflicts are recorded and the manuscript is reassigned. See the Conflict of Interest Policy.

7. Reviewer selection and reviewer suggestions

Reviewers are selected for subject expertise and absence of conflict. Authors may suggest reviewers and may request the exclusion of specific individuals with a stated reason; the handling editor is not bound by either request and always includes reviewers the authors did not name.

8. Corrections to the record

IJCIE corrects the published record when an error is established, through a correction notice, an expression of concern or a retraction, as appropriate. See the Article Correction, Retraction and Misconduct Policy.

9. Appeals and complaints

Authors may appeal a decision or complain about the process; the procedure and expected timelines are set out in the Complaints and Appeals Policy.

10. Advertising, sponsorship and direct marketing

IJCIE does not carry advertising. The journal does not send unsolicited bulk invitations to submit manuscripts, and any email claiming to solicit submissions on behalf of IJCIE from a domain other than ijcie.com should be reported to info@ijcie.com.