Complaints and Appeals Policy

Complaints and Appeals Policy

IJCIE takes complaints seriously and treats them as an opportunity to correct a mistake or improve a process. This page states what can be appealed, how, and what happens next.

1. Appealing an editorial decision

Authors may appeal a rejection. An appeal must:

  • be submitted by the corresponding author to info@ijcie.com within 30 days of the decision, with the manuscript ID in the subject line;
  • state precisely which points in the reviewers' or editor's assessment are considered factually incorrect, and give the evidence;
  • be a reasoned technical argument. Disagreement with a reviewer's judgement, or an assertion that the work is important, is not by itself a ground for appeal.

Process. The appeal is acknowledged within five working days. It is assessed by the Editor-in-Chief or, where the Editor-in-Chief took the original decision, by an Associate Editor who was not involved. Additional independent review may be sought. A decision is normally issued within four weeks. The decision on an appeal is final. Only one appeal per manuscript is considered, and a manuscript under appeal must not be submitted elsewhere.

2. Complaints about process, conduct or content

Complaints may concern editorial process (delays, failure to follow the published procedure), conduct (discourtesy, breach of confidentiality, conflict of interest), publication ethics (concerns about a published article) or the journal's policies and website.

StepWho actsTimeline
Acknowledgement of the complaintEditorial office5 working days
Investigation and responseEditor-in-Chief, or an uninvolved Associate Editor if the complaint concerns the Editor-in-Chief30 days
Escalation if the complainant is not satisfiedPublisher, DeepCognix AI Labs 30 further days
External referralThe complainant may refer the matter to COPE or to the authors' institution–

3. How to submit

Write to info@ijcie.com with "APPEAL" or "COMPLAINT" and the manuscript ID or DOI in the subject line, and set out the facts, dates and any supporting documents.

4. Principles we apply

  • The person handling a complaint has no involvement in the matter complained of.
  • Complainants are not disadvantaged in any future dealing with the journal.
  • Correspondence is confidential and is retained for at least five years.
  • Where a complaint is upheld, the journal states what went wrong and what it has changed.

5. What this policy does not cover

The journal cannot arbitrate disputes between co-authors, adjudicate institutional grievances, or conduct formal research misconduct investigations, which are matters for the authors' institutions. Concerns about a published article are handled under the Article Correction, Retraction and Misconduct Policy.