Duties of Reviewers
Duties of Reviewers
Peer review is the mechanism by which IJCIE decides what to publish, and reviewers therefore carry real responsibility for the quality of the journal. Reviewers who accept an invitation accept the following duties.
Contribution to editorial decisions
The reviewer assists the handling editor in reaching a decision and, through the review comments, assists the authors in improving the manuscript. A review should be a constructive technical document, not a verdict.
Promptness
A reviewer who feels unqualified to review a manuscript, or who cannot complete the review within the requested period of four weeks, should notify the editor immediately and decline, so that the manuscript can be reassigned without delay.
Confidentiality
Manuscripts received for review are confidential documents. They must not be shown to, or discussed with, anyone except as authorised by the editor. This applies equally to any generative artificial intelligence service: uploading a manuscript under review to an external AI tool is a breach of confidentiality and is not permitted. Reviewers who wish to use AI assistance for language must obtain the editor's prior agreement and must not disclose manuscript content.
Standards of objectivity
Reviews should be conducted objectively. Personal criticism of the author is inappropriate. Reviewers should express their views clearly with supporting arguments, and should distinguish between what is required for correctness and what is a matter of preference.
Acknowledgement of sources
Reviewers should identify relevant published work that has not been cited, and should draw the editor's attention to any substantial similarity or overlap between the manuscript under review and any other published work of which they have personal knowledge.
Disclosure and conflict of interest
Privileged information or ideas obtained through peer review must be kept confidential and not used for personal advantage. Reviewers must decline to review manuscripts in which they have a competing interest resulting from a collaborative, competitive, financial, institutional or personal relationship with any of the authors or institutions connected to the work.
What a review should cover
- Significance and originality of the contribution relative to existing work.
- Correctness of the technical development, derivations and assumptions.
- Adequacy of the experimental design, datasets, baselines and evaluation metrics.
- Whether the conclusions are actually supported by the reported evidence.
- Reproducibility: is there enough detail for a competent reader to repeat the work?
- Quality of referencing, figures, tables and English expression.
- Ethical compliance, including approvals, consent, data provenance and declarations.
- A clear recommendation with the reasons for it.
Recognition
IJCIE does not pay reviewers. On request, the editorial office will issue a certificate of review that does not disclose the manuscript reviewed, and reviewers may record their activity in external recognition services.






