Duties of Editors

Duties of Editors

Editors of IJCIE accept the following responsibilities on appointment.

Publication decisions

The handling editor is responsible for deciding which submitted articles are published, on the basis of validity, importance to researchers and readers, and fit with the journal's scope. The editor is guided by the journal's policies and by the legal requirements on defamation, copyright infringement and plagiarism, and may consult other editors or reviewers in reaching a decision.

Fair play

Manuscripts are evaluated on their intellectual content without regard to the race, gender, sexual orientation, religious belief, ethnic origin, citizenship, seniority, institutional affiliation or political philosophy of the authors.

Confidentiality

An editor must not disclose information about a submitted manuscript to anyone other than the corresponding author, reviewers, potential reviewers, other editorial advisers and the publisher, as appropriate. Unpublished material disclosed in a submission must not be used in an editor's own research without the written consent of the author.

Conflicts of interest

An editor must recuse from handling a manuscript in which they have a competing interest arising from a collaborative, financial, institutional, personal or other relationship with any of the authors, and must ask the Editor-in-Chief to reassign it. Manuscripts authored by an editor are handled independently, as described in the Editorial Policies.

Integrity of the published record

An editor who is presented with convincing evidence that a published article is erroneous or that misconduct has occurred must act: seeking an explanation from the authors, and where necessary publishing a correction, an expression of concern or a retraction. Errors must be corrected prominently, and the correction must be linked to the original article.

Engagement with the review process

Editors are expected to select reviewers with genuine subject expertise, to give reviewers adequate time and clear instructions, to read the reports critically rather than counting recommendations, and to communicate decisions with reasons that the authors can act on.

Vigilance

Editors are expected to be alert to signals of research and publication misconduct, including image manipulation, implausible results, undisclosed duplicate submission, citation manipulation, fabricated or non-existent references, and the undeclared use of generative artificial intelligence, and to investigate rather than to ignore them.

Timeliness

Editors are expected to move manuscripts through the workflow without avoidable delay and to keep authors informed when a stage takes longer than the indicative timeline published in the Publication Schedule.