Authorship Policy

Authorship Policy

1. Criteria for authorship

IJCIE applies the four ICMJE criteria. An author is a person who meets all of the following:

  1. made a substantial contribution to the conception or design of the work, or to the acquisition, analysis or interpretation of the data;
  2. drafted the work or revised it critically for important intellectual content;
  3. approved the version to be published;
  4. agreed to be accountable for all aspects of the work, including the integrity and accuracy of any part of it.

Contributors who meet fewer than all four criteria must be named in the Acknowledgements with their contribution described, not listed as authors.

2. Contributions that do not by themselves justify authorship

Acquisition of funding; general supervision of a research group or department; provision of equipment, computing resources, samples or data without intellectual involvement; language editing; technical assistance; and administrative support.

3. Practices that are not permitted

  • Gift or honorary authorship – naming a person who did not contribute, including a supervisor or head of department who was not involved.
  • Guest authorship – adding a senior name to increase the perceived standing of the paper.
  • Ghost authorship – omitting a person who did contribute substantially.
  • Authorship for sale – buying or selling a position in the author list, or purchasing a manuscript. IJCIE treats any evidence of paper-mill activity as serious misconduct and reports it to the institutions concerned.
  • Listing a generative AI system as an author. See the Use of Artificial Intelligence policy.

4. Order of authors and the corresponding author

The order of authors is decided by the authors themselves before submission and is not changed by the journal. The corresponding author acts on behalf of all co-authors, is responsible for communication with the journal at every stage, confirms that all co-authors have approved the submission, and handles queries after publication.

5. Contributor roles (CRediT)

At submission, the contribution of each author must be recorded using the CRediT taxonomy (conceptualisation, methodology, software, validation, formal analysis, investigation, resources, data curation, writing – original draft, writing – review and editing, visualisation, supervision, project administration, funding acquisition). Contributor roles are published with the article.

6. Changes to the author list

Any addition, removal or reordering of authors after submission requires:

  • a written request from the corresponding author giving the reason for the change; and
  • written confirmation of agreement from every author, including the author being added or removed.

The handling editor considers the request; changes are not made during the review of a revision. Requests for changes after publication are considered only in exceptional circumstances and result in a published correction notice.

7. Authorship disputes

IJCIE does not arbitrate authorship disputes. If a dispute arises, the manuscript is held and, if already accepted, publication is suspended until the authors provide a written resolution or the matter is settled by their institutions. A dispute concerning a published article is handled under COPE guidance and may result in a correction or an expression of concern.

8. Deceased or unavailable authors

Where an author dies or cannot be contacted, the corresponding author must inform the editorial office. The person remains an author, with a footnote recording the circumstances, and the remaining authors take responsibility for the accuracy of the final version.

9. Affiliations

Affiliations must be those at which the reported work was carried out. A subsequent affiliation may be added as a present address footnote. Listing an institution with which an author has no genuine connection is misconduct.