Article Correction, Retraction and Misconduct Policy

Article Correction, Retraction, Withdrawal and Misconduct Policy

IJCIE is responsible for the integrity of what it has published. Errors are corrected openly, and the published record is never altered silently. All notices follow COPE guidance, are published in the current issue, carry their own DOI, and are permanently linked to and from the original article.

1. Correction (erratum / corrigendum)

Used when a published article contains an error that affects the record but not the validity of the results or conclusions: for example an incorrect figure, a mislabelled axis, an error in an author's name or affiliation, a missing funding or conflict declaration, or a wrong reference.

  • Corrigendum: the error was made by the authors.
  • Erratum: the error was introduced by the journal in production.

The original article remains available and unchanged; a prominent link to the correction notice is added to the article page.

2. Expression of concern

Issued when there is well-founded concern about the integrity or reliability of a published article but the investigation is not complete, the institution's inquiry is unresolved, or the evidence is inconclusive. The notice states what is in question and is replaced by a correction or retraction when the matter is resolved.

3. Retraction

A retraction is issued when the findings are unreliable or the article breaches publication ethics, including:

  • fabrication, falsification or manipulation of data or images;
  • plagiarism, including undisclosed text recycling of a substantial kind;
  • redundant or duplicate publication;
  • major errors that invalidate the conclusions, whether or not they were deliberate;
  • unethical research, such as absent ethical approval or absent informed consent;
  • fabricated references or content, including undeclared generative AI output;
  • paper-mill origin, sold authorship, or compromised peer review;
  • copyright infringement or other legal defect.

The retracted article is not removed. It remains online, clearly watermarked "RETRACTED", with a retraction notice stating who is retracting the article and why, and both are linked. The retraction is deposited with Crossref so that it propagates to indexing services.

4. Removal

In the rare case where an article is defamatory, infringes a legal right, is subject to a court order, or presents a serious health risk if acted upon, the content may be removed. The metadata, title, authors and a notice explaining the removal remain in place so that the DOI continues to resolve.

5. Withdrawal before publication

Authors may withdraw a manuscript before a decision by written request from the corresponding author, without penalty. Withdrawal after acceptance requires the written agreement of all authors and is granted only for good reason; withdrawal in order to submit the same work elsewhere is a breach of publication ethics and may be reported to the authors' institutions.

6. How allegations are handled

  1. Receipt. Allegations are sent to info@ijcie.com and are acknowledged within five working days. Anonymous allegations are considered on the strength of the evidence offered.
  2. Preliminary assessment by the Editor-in-Chief, using the applicable COPE flowchart, normally within thirty days.
  3. Author response. The corresponding author is presented with the specific concerns and given at least fourteen days to respond on behalf of all authors.
  4. Investigation. Where necessary, independent experts are consulted and the authors' institutions are asked to conduct a formal inquiry. IJCIE does not conduct institutional investigations itself.
  5. Outcome. No action, correction, expression of concern, or retraction; the decision and reasons are communicated to the authors and to the person who raised the concern.
  6. Sanctions. In substantiated cases of serious misconduct, the journal may refuse submissions from the authors involved for up to three years and inform their institutions and, where appropriate, their funders.

Confidentiality is maintained throughout, and the parties may appeal under the Complaints and Appeals Policy.

7. Post-publication discussion

Readers who wish to comment on a published article should write to the editorial office. Substantive comments may be published as a letter, with the authors invited to reply in the same issue.